Herb Academy

Professional Online Herbalist Training

  • Home
  • My Courses
    • My Achievements
    • My Account
  • Training Paths
  • Monographs
  • Articles
  • Enrollments

September 30, 2014

The Irony of the “No-Result” Result in Herbal Medicine

no-result graphicAs herbal medicine progresses back to its former position of popularity, there is an increasing inclination on the part of the media to do “herbal exposés” that tend to be deceptive, sensationalist, and sometimes irrational.

Fortunately, as you venture deeper into your study of the subject, you will be able to distinguish these hype pieces from informative journalism.

One that rears its ugly head every now and then is the myth that: “If a herb has the power to heal, then it can harm.” Technically, this is probably true as almost every natural healing system has an adage akin to “The dose makes the poison.”

But as herbalist Robyn Landis (1997) explains, it’s important to recognize that this is true of all drugs and all foods as well as herbs. It is not especially true of herbs. To the contrary, herbs are much more difficult to misuse than drugs because of the synergy of all the ingredients they contain.

Landis also explains that:

“Doctors and scientists often assume that any active substance must have side effects, because their experience is with drugs, and drugs by their very nature will have side effects. Indeed, any rational decision regarding whether to use a drug begins with the acknowledgement that there will be side effects, and weighs that unavoidable cost against the potential benefits of the drug. But the activity of a whole plant, with all its compounds intact, simply is not comparable to the action of a single concentrated compound.”

As herbalist Michael Moore puts it:

“A physician’s biochemical tools are drugs. By extension, docs may rightly presume that any agent capable of promoting change probably has similar potential for side effects…”

Ironically, the expectation of side effects for drugs is such a given that side effects can come to be seen as a necessary sign of value, a warped sort of status symbol says Landis. Thus a corollary myth is: “If a herb doesn’t have the power to harm, then it can’t heal.”

Observes herbalist Moore: “Carried to an irrational extreme, some medical folks feel that anything without potential side effects is quackery. This, of course, leaves any alternative approach in a Catch-22 bind.”

A good case in point can be found in the realm of preventative medicine. It is a phenomenon herbalist Robyn Landis coined the “no-result” result:

“One of the ironies of taking good care of yourself in [herbal medicine] is what I call the “no-result” result. We are not accustomed to measuring our success by what doesn’t happen. We want to see something take place, even if it means being very ill and getting heroically “cured”. A shift in thinking is in order here: No news is good news. There are countless all-too-common health catastrophes whose absence in your life will confirm your success.”

Pause and Reflect

  1. Take a few minutes to think about the above. How do you feel about the “no-result” result? Does it make sense to you?
  2. Write down your thoughts and feelings or leave a Reply below.
Pin
Share
0 Shares

Article by 62 Comments

Comments

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

  1. dheeonline says

    April 20, 2022 at 4:10 am

    I believe on what the ‘no-result’ result says – especially in the case of natural medicine. We are ‘programmed’ to believe that the most effective treatment is one that shows evident result. We forgot that many factors, like the herbs we take in as food are medicine in themselves as they maintain our health. Without taking them in, our health will deteriorate resulting in diseases. So, the mere fact that they are maintaining the workings of our body are often overlooked.

    Log in to Reply
  2. Colin Jardine says

    March 8, 2022 at 1:39 pm

    No Result makes absolute sense. If I am in unbearable pain, I will most likely take a drug prescription for immediate relief. On the other hand, if I am on a path to improve overall health, I cannot expect to see results immediately. If I have a condition that can be treated naturally and does not demand a “quick fix”, I will be happy with a no result result in the very short term. in the short to medium term, I would be looking for and noting any noticeable changes in my condition. I cannot do this with drugs because my kidneys and liver will go on strike at some point. Herbs on the other hand are a lot more organ friendly.

    Log in to Reply
  3. ÖMER AYDIN says

    August 31, 2021 at 7:01 pm

    Bana göre sonuç alınamaması, bitkisel ilaçların her zaman yan etkileri olmamasına rağmen, işe yaramadığı anlamına gelmez. İyileşmek için daha hasta olmana gerek yok. Herhangi bir rahatsızlık hissederseniz, danışın ve hemen durun.

    Log in to Reply
  4. Dion Le Roux says

    February 7, 2021 at 8:10 pm

    The term “no result” is unfortunate as it is suggestively negative. In reality, “no result” actually speaks to the notion of wellness. So yes, herbs may only be applied as a treatment for ailments but to do only this would be severely limiting. There is a strong element of being able to contribute to wellness and so “no result” is a fabulous outcome.

    Log in to Reply
  5. patricia. [email protected] says

    September 4, 2020 at 9:48 pm

    No results results to me means that although herbal medicine does not always have side effects doesn’t mean it is not working. You don’t have to be sicker to get well. If you experience any discomfort you consult and stop immediately.

    Log in to Reply
« Older Comments

LEARNER LOGIN

Lost your Password? Recover it here

Course Progress

Basic Herbal Medicine Making
Module 1 Principles of Herbal Medicine Making-
Unit 1 The Battle for the Body  - Preview
Unit 2 Types of Healing
Unit 3 How the "Green People" Came to Our Aid (a Cherokee Tale)
Unit 4 The Irony of the "No-Result" Result in Herbal Medicine  - Preview
Unit 5 How To Use Herbal Medicine Safely  - Preview
Unit 6 Herbalism is NOT a Spectator Sport  - Preview
Unit 7 Quiz 1: The Principles of Herbal Medicine Making
Module 2 The Folk Method of Herbal Medicine Making-
Unit 1 Setting Up A Basic Herbal Apothecary At Home
Unit 2 The 5 Rules of Herbal Medicine Making
Unit 3 The Folk Method of Preparing an Infusion
Unit 4 The Folk Method of Preparing a Decoction
Unit 5 The Folk Method of Preparing a Poultice
Unit 6 Quiz 2 - The Folk Method of Medicine Making

Browse Monographs by Application

abdominal pain abscesses aphrodisiac backache burns and scalds colds colic constipation convulsions corns cough diabetes diarrhoea divining dizziness dysentery eczema emetic enema epilepsy evil fever flu fodder furniture haemorrhoids headache impotence indigestion infertility insomnia measles menses painful joints pimples purgative snakebite snakes snuff sores sore throat syphilis tonic venereal disease wounds

Popular Courses

  • cooking with herbs and spices Cooking With Herbs and Spices - Mini Masterclass
    Rated 4.76 out of 5
    $15.92
  • level 6 professional family herbalist Professional Family Herbalist - Complete 12-in-1 Course Bundle $455.12 $239.60
  • level 3 professional family herbalist course bundle Level 3 Professional Family Herbalist: 6-in-1 Course Bundle $199.60 $119.60

Recent Comments

  • Bridgette Du Preez on Accreditation and Serving Clients
  • Bridgette Du Preez on Optional Reading: Gardening Books
  • Bridgette Du Preez on Finding The Best Spot(s)
  • Bridgette Du Preez on 7 Reasons For Starting A Small Food Garden
  • Bridgette Du Preez on The Three Best Sustainable Gardening Systems

Member Admin

  • About
  • FAQ’s
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

Registrations

  • Amateur Herbalist
  • Professional Herbalist
  • Master Green Healer
  • Masterclasses

Need Help?

+27 82 416 7145

Connect With Us

  • E-mail
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • RSS

Copyright © 2004 – 2022 All Rights Reserved